Investing With a Climate Lens

June 06, 2022

In this episode of Engaging Alternatives Spotlight, Elana Margulies-Snyderman, Senior Manager, Publications, EisnerAmper, speaks with Zach Stein, Co-Founder of Carbon Collective, a San Francisco-based investment adviser focused on solving climate change. He shares his outlook for investing in companies focused on addressing climate change, including the greatest opportunities and challenges, thoughts on the SEC’s push for more transparency, how the firm is integrating DEI and more. 


Transcript

Elana Margulies-Snyderman:Hello and welcome to the EisnerAmper Podcast Series. I'm your host, Elana Margulies-Snyderman. And with me today is Zach Stein, co-founder Carbon Collective, a San Francisco-based investment advisor focused on solving climate change. Today Zach will share with us his outlook for investing in companies focused on addressing climate change, including the greatest opportunities and challenges, thoughts on the SEC's push for more transparency, how the firm is integrating DEI and more. Hi, Zach. Thanks for being with me today.
Zach Stein:Hey, Elana. So glad to be here.

Ems:
Absolutely. So Zach, to kick off, I'd like you to tell us a little about Carbon Collective and how you got to where you are today.
Zs:Sure. So my name is Zach Stein, co-founder of Carbon Collective. So glad for the intro. Carbon Collective is an investment advisor that is working to redefine sustainable investing. The number-one issue for so many of us within sustainability is climate change and we know what we need to do to solve climate change. We actually need sustainable investing to work. We need to be investing as a globe 10 to 20 times more than we are today into climate solutions per year. That's a big gap that we need to fill.

We also need to basically stop all new investments into fossil fuel expansion. That is what we have to do. We cannot solve climate change without investing. We literally have to put a lot of solar panels on the ground. So what Wall Street labels as sustainable does not really align with that reality. It often even has more fossil fuels than it does climate solutions. So we build comprehensive portfolios that make sense for something like your IRA but that are built with a clear theory of change of every part that's in it to help us build towards that world that we need to solve our most critical sustainable issue.
Ems:Great, Zach, thanks for that overview of your firm, your background. So to dive a little deeper, I'd like you to share your outlook for investing in companies that seek to solve climate change.
Zs:So we get this question a lot and maybe I could rephrase it in a different way, which is we get people coming to Carbon Collective and they're like, Hey, all right, I'm ready. This is super cool. I want to align my invest with my values and I know I'm going to perform a percentage point or two worse, but that's okay. I accept that.

And we think that that outlook is fundamentally incorrect. This is a myth around sustainable investing. The counter-myth to that is that fossil fuels are an important part of a balanced portfolio and, in spite of what has happened in the past year with the energy industry, the trend is very much in the opposite. A portfolio of the S & P 500 that would've been divested from fossil fuels from 1989 to the present would still be outperforming the overall S & P 500 in general, one with fossil fuels in it.

And then looking ahead, we see what's happening with the fossil fuel industry right now and with the large share buybacks, increasing of dividends. This is some extent to them waving the white flag and acknowledging that their prospects for long-term growth aren't great. 50% of the oil that is used in the US is used on our roadways. It's our cars and trucks. There is a better technology that is here that doesn't use oil to do the same thing. It is faster, stronger, much roomier, much safer, costs a 10th as much to maintain because it has a 10th of the moving parts. And you can literally run a Tesla for over a million miles. Within the next five years, electric cars are likely going to be less expensive to purchase upfront than a gas-powered car. We're in the middle of a technological shift and replacement.

So that is a lot of oil's market share that is being transitioned out, same thing in electricity. So when we look at the future prospects of something like oil and energy as it's traditionally been known, it's hard to see where those avenues are for long-term growth. And instead, what we see is the companies that are replacing them, these are the ones that are quickly eating up those market share. And so for us as long-term investors who are saving for retirement, those are the type of companies that we'd much rather be in than an industry that is fundamentally in decline.
Ems:Zach, to shift gears a little bit, where do you see some of the greatest challenges with what you do from an investing perspective?
Zs:It is those underlying myths right now that help perpetuate the fossil fuel industry and hold back a lot of climate solutions. It's changing, but when we look at efficient market hypothesis, it is broadly correct. Stocks are priced based upon largely publicly available information. What we don't often think about is that underlying narratives that we just hold as fundamentally true are a part of that publicly available information. So that narrative that fossil fuels are an important part, that you need them in order to get performance that actually helps perpetuate the performance of fossil fuel companies and those stocks on it.

Similarly, that counter narrative that sustainable investing is only for Greenies like me and is fundamentally a charitable act also keeps those prices down. And so it is those that kind of are the biggest blockers here. I gave a webinar recently to a bunch of students at Cal and these narratives were still very much baked in and those type of questions. So it's even for 20-year olds who very much are seeing ahead, that is the type of thing that we are still coming against. So it's the story that in some ways is still so much the problem.
Ems:Zach, I wanted to ask you, what are your thoughts on the SEC's push for increased transparency? And what would this mean for a firm like yours?
Zs:So we absolutely need more transparency here. Climate risk is not something that is being adequately priced into the overall stock market right now. If it was, then we would be likely seeing a very different landscape of what we see today. Part of the way to get that is through increased transparency in the same way that now banks after the recession of 2008 are required by law to do stress tests and show their ability to bounce back from debt crises and things like that and disclose that type of risk, so investors can know about them.

We need to see the same in regards to climate change, because it is the biggest disruptor of our global economic system that is coming, and it is already here and it is getting worse. So it is something that we absolutely need more of. What we also can't have, though, is on a company-based level. We can't have it getting in the way of action. There are just certain things that we know need to happen, regardless of what, as a company, your specific carbon footprint is. To solve climate change, we need you to use a hundred percent renewable energy. We need you to switch your fleet to being all electric. I think often in the climate space in general, we can let measurement get in the way of action. We need both and we believe that they can be done in parallel path.
Ems:Zach, I'd be remiss if we fail to discuss on today's podcast diversity, equity, and inclusion and how you are integrating it both at the firm level and through your investments.
Zs:Yes, it is absolutely key. At the firm level, the place to address this is in hiring. It is how do you make sure that the top of the funnel of your hiring process is you are getting candidates that match the diversity in terms of not just racial background but religion and economic background and educational background as well, to make sure that we have that in the firm. This is something that I believe for literally every corporation in America should always be seen as a work in progress.

I think any company that says we're done with this is not fully acknowledging the level of historic racism and sexism that we are all born into. So we, Carbon Collective, are very much one of those companies where it's our job, especially as leaders and as a white male who is in this position, to say we always need to keep our eye on this prize and never feel like we have done enough with it.

On the investment side, this is an area where you can use those tools of engagement. So how are we pressuring companies right now? Tesla is in the news, because they were kicked out of the S & P's ESG index. As a side note, this is absolutely ridiculous that it's the case. Tesla certainly has things that it needs to improve on its social and on its governance especially, but the fact that their core product is they are the leader in solving one of the most important issues of climate change, which is electric vehicles and the solutions there, their core product does that.

Whereas we have companies whose core products like ExxonMobil are causing the number-one issue in E still in that is ridiculous and we believe undermines ESG as a whole as a framework. Coming back to your question though, in looking at a company like Tesla, who has a lot that they need to improve on that level, that is where we see the type of engaging, of we need to work with our friends and those companies that are building solutions. And again, that same level of never being satisfied and never saying that any company is perfect because it's impossible to achieve. But that equally means that we need to push to get there.
Ems:Zach, we've covered a lot of ground today, and I wanted to see if you have any final thoughts you'd like to share with us today.
Zs:I think I would like to share two things. One is reiterating the challenge to the narratives of fossil fuels and energy stocks of being a necessary evil in a balanced portfolio. And two, the role of sustainable investing as one that is fundamentally charitable. Zoom out, take that long view, and look at what is the market share. It could be hard to see in a world that is run by fossil fuels today, but when we project 10 to 20 years ahead, if you are an investor, start asking yourself those types of questions.

And then the second thing is, if any of your listeners are deeply concerned about climate change and are looking for how to get involved and what to do about it. The place that we always say to start is do the big things in your life. And those are often the hardest things to do, but it's to change the gears of how your life works to orient with solving our greatest issue.

So for example, where you bank. It's kind of a pain is to change where you bank. You have to look up all your auto deposits and write them down and then set up the new bank and make sure it all gets linked up and do the transfer, close your old one. But once you do it, and you can know that your deposits are no longer being used to finance fossil fuel expansion and instead hopefully being used for something that's on the positive side of the ledger, that is big. And then once you're done with it, it is a big decision. You get to pick it up. You just get to put it down. After that you're just banking. You're not having to think about what you're eating for lunch or what you're doing in the grocery store or while shopping.

So banking, investing, how you generate your electricity, how you transport yourself, how you cook your food. These are a lot of the really big questions that we like to urge people to start with, because once you do it, decision fatigue is a real thing. You'll be on the other side and you'll fundamentally just be living a more sustainable life.
Ems:Well, Zach, I wanted to thank you so much for sharing your perspective with our listeners today. And thank you for listening to the EisnerAmper podcast series. Visit eisneramper.com for more information on this and a host of other topics and join us for our next EisnerAmper podcast, when we get down to business.

Transcribed by Rev.com

About Elana Margulies-Snyderman

Elana Margulies-Snyderman is an investment industry reporter and writer who develops articles, opinion pieces and original research designed to help illuminate the most challenging issues confronting fund managers and executives.


More in This Series

Convexity Strategies
Convexity Strategies

In this episode of Engaging Alternatives Spotlight, Elana Margulies-Snyderman, Director, Publications, EisnerAmper, speaks with Nancy Davis, Chief Investment Officer of Quadratic Capital Management, a Greenwich, Connecticut-based investment advisory firm focused on convexity strategies.

Deep Tech Venture Capital Investing
Deep Tech Venture Capital Investing

In this episode of Engaging Alternatives Spotlight, Elana Margulies-Snyderman, Director, Publications, EisnerAmper, speaks with James Wang, General Partner, Creative Ventures, a deep tech venture firm investing in early-stage companies. He shares his outlook for VC investing in early-stage companies, including the greatest opportunities and challenges, how the firm is embracing DEI and more.

Emerging Markets Infrastructure Debt
Emerging Markets Infrastructure Debt

A discussion with Susan Wisialko, Founder and CIO of Global Infrastructure Finance, who shares her outlook for investing in emerging markets infrastructure debt, including the greatest opportunities and challenges, how the firm is integrating ESG, DEI and more.

ESG Investing
ESG Investing

A discussion with Ima Edomwonyi, Executive & Senior ESG Analyst at Franklin Mutual Advisers who shares his outlook for ESG including the greatest opportunities and challenges, how the firm integrates it and more.  

Systematic Investing
Systematic Investing

A discussion on the outlook for systematic investing including the greatest opportunities and challenges, how the firm is integrating ESG, DEI and more.

Venture Capital Investing in Women-Owned Entrepreneurs
Venture Capital Investing in Women-Owned Entrepreneurs

In this episode of Engaging Alternatives Spotlight, Elana Margulies-Snyderman, Director, Publications, EisnerAmper, speaks with Victoria Pettibone, Chief Investment Officer & Managing Partner, Astia Fund, a Silicon Valley-based early-stage venture capital fund that invests in women entrepreneurs.

Private Credit
Private Credit

A discussion with with Danielle Brown, CEO, Altriarch Capital Management on her outlook for private credit, including the greatest opportunities and challenges, her experience being a woman investment manager in the industry, and how the firm is embracing DEI. 

Growth Equity Investing in Hospitality & Hospitality Tech
Growth Equity Investing in Hospitality & Hospitality Tech

In this episode of Engaging Alternatives Spotlight, Elana Margulies-Snyderman, Senior Manager, Publications, EisnerAmper, speaks with Mark Leavitt, Managing Partner & Co-Founder of Enlightened Hospitality Investments, a New York-based growth equity fund he co-founded with restauranteur Danny Meyer. He shares his outlook for investing in hospitality and hospitality tech including the greatest opportunities and challenges, how the firm is integrating ESG, DEI and more.

 Investing With Purpose
Investing With Purpose

The outlook for sustainable investing including the greatest opportunities and challenges, thoughts on the SEC’s rules to enhance ESG disclosures, how the firm is addressing DEI and more.

Interval Funds
Interval Funds

Kim Flynn, Alternative Investments, XA Investments, shares her views on interval funds including the greatest opportunities and challenges, how the firm integrates ESG, the challenges of making private investments more accessible for every investor and more.

The “Social” Component of ESG Investing
The “Social” Component of ESG Investing

A discussion on the “S” or “Social” component of ESG investing, exclusively on economic inclusion and high-volume responsible lending to small businesses including but not limited to women, people of color, veteran-owned businesses and those in low income areas.

Systematic Global Macro Investing
Systematic Global Macro Investing

A discussion on the outlook for systematic global macro investing, including the greatest opportunities and challenges, yield investing, ESG and thoughts on the SEC’s push for enhanced transparency.

80/20 Rule for Investing
80/20 Rule for Investing

A discussion on the 80/20 rule and how it applies to investing, the SEC’s approach to 100% disclosure, DEI and more.

Water Investing
Water Investing

EisnerAmper speaks with Matt Diserio, President of Water Asset Management, a New York City and San Francisco-based investment manager deemed one of the first water industry investors investing exclusively in companies and assets that ensure water quality and supply.

ESG Real Estate Loans
ESG Real Estate Loans

A discussion with Chris Callahan, President & CEO of X-Caliber Capital about his views on investing in ESG-focused real estate loans, including the greatest opportunities and challenges in the space, what the firm is doing to champion DEI and more.

Crypto Hedge Fund Investing
Crypto Hedge Fund Investing

In this episode of Engaging Alternatives Spotlight, Elana Margulies-Snyderman speaks with Sadie Raney, Co-Founder and CEO at crypto hedge fund Strix Leviathan and Co-Founder at crypto robo advisor Makara.

ESG from a Risk Management and Investment Perspective
ESG from a Risk Management and Investment Perspective

A conversation with Patrick Ghali, Managing Partner of Sussex Partners, who shares his outlook for the alternative investment industry, including strategies he sees most attractive and ones that face the biggest challenges.

Capital Raising in a Hybrid World
Capital Raising in a Hybrid World

The outlook for capital raising in a mainly virtual world, how he pivoted during COVID-19, advice he has to successfully raise capital and finally, what he anticipates capital raising will be like post-COVID-19.

Equity Risk Management
Equity Risk Management

Ricardo Cortez, Co-CEO of Broadmark Asset Management, shares with us his background of how he got into investing, his outlook for the hedge fund industry, including the greatest opportunities and challenges, and how he is championing DEI on both a firm-level and throughout the alternative investments industry as a whole.

Outlook for the Fund of Hedge Fund Industry
Outlook for the Fund of Hedge Fund Industry

Elana Margulies-Snyderman speaks with Luis D’Amato, Partner and Portfolio Manager of Aston Capital Management. He shares his background of how he got into investing, his outlook for the fund of hedge fund industry.

Climate Change
Climate Change

In this episode of Engaging Alternatives Spotlight, Elana Margulies-Snyderman speaks with Tom Soto, Founder and Managing Partner of the Diverse Communities Impact Fund (DCIF), a Latino-owned lower middle market impact-focused private equity fund based in Los Angeles.

U.S. Lower Middle Market Investing
U.S. Lower Middle Market Investing

In this episode of Engaging Alternatives Spotlight, Elana Margulies-Snyderman speaks with Brett Hickey of Star Mountain Capital who shares his views on the U.S. lower middle market, and the various opportunities he sees in making direct investments.

Distressed Credit and Special Situations Opportunities
Distressed Credit and Special Situations Opportunities

In this episode, Cindy Chen Delano of Invictus Global Management shares her non-traditional path into money management, her outlook on alternative investments with respect to distressed credit and special situations, her experience being a woman money manager, what she is doing to encourage more women to go into investing, and how the firm is embracing D&I.

Multi-Strategy Hedge Fund and Opportunistic Credit Investing
Multi-Strategy Hedge Fund and Opportunistic Credit Investing

Elana Margulies-Snyderman speaks with Tracy McHale Stuart, Managing Partner and Chief Executive Officer of Corbin Capital Partners. She shares her views on alternative investments, how the firm has incorporated ESG into its principles, her experience being a woman in alternative investments, what the firm is doing to champion D&I and more.

Investing in Diverse and Emerging Managers
Investing in Diverse and Emerging Managers

Elana Margulies-Snyderman speaks with Kelly Chesney, Co-Founder of Pluscios Management. She shares her views on alternative investments, how she got into money management, how her firm has been a pioneer in investing in diverse and emerging managers, her experience being a women in investing, what her firm is doing to champion more women at a young age to foray into money management.

Private Equity Investing in Media and Entertainment
Private Equity Investing in Media and Entertainment

In this episode of we speak with Vania Schlogel about her views on private equity, the specific opportunities she sees, why she opened an office in South Korea, her experience being a woman in the industry and more.

Latino Money Manager Empowers Young Hispanics to Foray Into Money Management
Latino Money Manager Empowers Young Hispanics to Foray Into Money Management

Lorenzo Esparza discusses his views on alternative investments, how he got into money management, what is he doing to champion more young Hispanics to go into investing careers.

Raising Capital When Everyone Is Scared: A Conversation with Garry Jensen
Raising Capital When Everyone Is Scared: A Conversation with Garry Jensen

As we continue to explore the capital raising environment for funds in a virtual context against a backdrop of economic uncertainty, we turn to Garry Jensen, Managing Partner of Jensen Capital Partners, to get his insights.

Raising Capital When Everyone Is Scared: Do Investors Really Buy Low?
Raising Capital When Everyone Is Scared: Do Investors Really Buy Low?

In this podcast, we look to Julia Mord for her perspective on asset allocation, manager selection, and market conditions.

Innovation In Private Equity Using Structured Financial Products
Innovation In Private Equity Using Structured Financial Products

In this podcast Christopher Mizer of Vivaris Capital, delves into what structured financial products are and why they are attractive investment opportunities to investors.