M&A Purchase Accounting for Private Companies: Key Issues to Address Early
- Published
- Nov 16, 2026
- Share
Key Takeaways
- Private companies apply ASC 805 to decide whether an acquisition is a business combination or an asset acquisition, and management should reach that conclusion early in the deal, not at year-end close.
- An acquired set is not a business when substantially all of the fair value of the gross assets sits in a single identifiable asset or a group of similar assets, so the deal is an asset acquisition.
- Goodwill is recognized only in a business combination, and acquisition-related costs are generally expensed in a business combination but capitalized in an asset acquisition.
- Eligible private companies can amortize goodwill over ten years or less and fold certain customer-related intangibles and noncompetition agreements into goodwill, though later capital markets transactions could require unwinding those elections.
- Earnout payments forfeited when the recipient leaves the organization are a common indicator of post-acquisition compensation expense rather than purchase consideration.
- Pushdown accounting is irrevocable once elected for a change-in-control event, and it can change future earnings patterns and debt covenant calculations.
Global mergers and acquisitions (M&A) are running at near-record levels in the first nine months of 2026, driven largely by megadeals, heavy technology investment, and the strongest year for private equity-backed dealmaking. The middle-market activity is following a similar path, fueled by private equity firms under pressure to exit holdings and deploy capital. That pressure is drawing privately held companies into the market with acquisitions, mergers, and divestitures.
For owners, finance leaders, and investors, the implications are ongoing due diligence efforts, closer scrutiny of financing structures and accounting records, and, lastly, demanding integration of systems and workforce. Understanding how these forces affect your position is the first step toward acting on them with confidence.
When contemplating and executing these activities, private companies often face some complex purchase accounting issues in the application of ASC 805, Business Combinations. While financial reporting may often be viewed as a compliance exercise, the implications resulting from conclusions reached in mergers and acquisitions can materially affect the financial reporting requirements, future earnings, key performance indicators, and covenant and borrowing capacity. This article highlights some common issues encountered in practice and considerations that management and their advisors should evaluate early in the deal-making process.
Is It an Asset Acquisition or a Business Combination Under ASC 805?
One of the first questions is “what is being bought?”
ASC 805 provides an optional concentration test, commonly referred to as the "screen test." If substantially all of the fair value of the gross assets acquired is concentrated in a single identifiable asset or a group of similar identifiable assets, the acquired set is not a business. It is accounted for as an asset acquisition.
The conclusion is important because the accounting differs significantly. For example:
- Goodwill may only be recognized in a business combination.
- Acquisition-related costs are generally expensed in a business combination, but direct transaction costs are capitalized in an asset acquisition.
- Contingent consideration accounting may differ.
As the accounting and reporting consequences may be significant and irreversible, management should assess the asset-versus-business conclusion early in the transaction process rather than as part of the year-end close.
What Private Company Accounting Alternatives Can Simplify Purchase Accounting?
Eligible private companies have several accounting alternatives that can reduce the cost and complexity associated with purchase accounting.
The most common alternatives include:
- Goodwill amortization, which permits goodwill to be amortized over ten years (or less if appropriate).
- The identifiable intangible asset alternative, which allows certain customer-related intangible assets and noncompetition agreements to be included in goodwill rather than recognized separately.
While these alternatives can reduce valuation costs and simplify ongoing accounting, companies should consider future plans before electing them. Financial statements may become less comparable to public-company peers, and future capital market transactions could require these alternatives to be unwound and for the Company to record the transactions without them.
Common Purchase Accounting Challenges
Valuation Assumptions and Forecasts
Purchase price allocations often rely heavily on management forecasts to determine the fair value of acquired intangible assets and contingent consideration. One of the most common issues identified during audits is the use of overly optimistic projections developed during transaction negotiations. Fair value measurements should reflect assumptions that market participants would use rather than acquisition-specific expectations or aggressive deal models.
Areas frequently challenged include:
- Revenue growth assumptions
- Customer attrition rates
- Expected synergies
Valuation assumptions involve judgment and estimates, and the more supportable and consistent projections, consistent with other forecasts used throughout the organization, may be viewed more positively and as more relevant in the due diligence and valuation process.
Contingent Consideration and Earnouts
Earnouts remain one of the most judgmental aspects of business combination accounting, especially given their potential impact on future earnings. The key question is whether future payments represent:
- Additional purchase consideration, or
- Compensation for post-acquisition services.
This distinction can have a substantial impact on earnings. Amounts treated as contingent consideration are generally included in purchase accounting, while amounts treated as compensation are recognized as post-acquisition expense. One of the common indicators of compensation is when payments are forfeited if the recipient terminates employment. Payments that are not dependent on continued employment may be more indicative of purchase consideration.
Determining Useful Lives of Intangible Assets
Although significant attention is typically devoted to valuation, useful-life determinations often receive less scrutiny. The selected life directly affects future amortization expense and should be consistent with the economics of the acquired asset and assumptions used in the valuation model. Common pitfalls include:
- Selecting overly long useful lives to reduce amortization expense
- Ignoring technological obsolescence or customer attrition trends
- Inconsistencies between valuation assumptions and assigned useful lives
Should Pushdown Accounting Be Elected?
Following a change-in-control transaction, an acquired company may elect pushdown accounting in its separate financial statements. Pushdown accounting allows the acquiree to reflect the acquirer's new basis of accounting, including fair value adjustments and goodwill recognized in the acquisition. Potential benefits include:
- Alignment with the parent company's accounting records
- Reduced complexity in maintaining separate accounting bases
- Simplified future financial reporting
Potential drawbacks include:
- Changes to future earnings patterns due to depreciation, amortization, and other fair value adjustments
- Possible impacts on debt covenant calculations and financial metrics
- An irrevocable election once made for a particular change-in-control event
Accordingly, the decision should be evaluated strategically and thoroughly with the acquirer and the newly acquired company.
Why Early Planning Matters for Purchase Accounting
For privately held organizations, business acquisitions create opportunity, but one that involves far more collaboration with internal financial teams and external advisors than recording goodwill and obtaining a valuation report. Judgments made during purchase accounting frequently affect financial reporting for years after a transaction closes. Analyzing these transactions early and involving your trusted accounting advisors at the start of the process can help avoid surprises during the audit and improve the quality and consistency of post-acquisition financial reporting.
Whether you’re considering a sale, an acquisition, or a new investor, start early: assess your financial readiness, test your financing assumptions, and set timelines that reflect current conditions. Our assurance team can work with you to evaluate your options and move forward with confidence.
What's on Your Mind?
Start a conversation with the team