Tax Considerations That Shape Real Estate Funds
- Published
- Nov 10, 2026
- Topics
- Share
This webinar covered the key tax considerations across the real estate fund lifecycle, from acquisition structuring to wind-down planning, and how proactive coordination can prevent costly surprises for fund managers and investors.
Transcript
Michael Torhan:
Great. Thank you, Bella. Thank you, Josh and Pan for joining me today. And thank you for everybody who's logged into this. Like Bella mentioned, the goal of today's webinar is to talk about all the tax considerations that impact real estate funds. And you'll see we broke apart the schedule today into really three main sessions and plus an additional session. So we're really going to talk about all the tax considerations at the beginning of a fund. So when you're starting and structuring a new fund, we're going to talk about the considerations for operating a fund as well as those at the end when you're winding down a fund. And then we'll talk a little bit if time permits about distribution planning and what distributions look like throughout the life of a fund. So the part one, like I mentioned, is starting and structuring a fund.
One of the first questions when you're thinking about launching a new fund really comes down to what is the overall structure and economics of the fund going to look like? And there's a few different standard models and there's probably a lot of iterations of different types of structures and waterfall economics. We'll get into each of those concepts throughout the webinar. But the three main common models for funds are closed-ended funds where there's a defined term, investors commit to your fund. Once they're committed, they stay in the fund till the end. There's evergreen funds, which are also sometimes called open-ended funds. Those offer a little bit more liquidity to investors. There's options for investors to come in and out of those funds. And then there's also deal-by-deal funds.
We've actually been a lot more in the market where certain investors historically that have just been committing to discretionary funds where managers and sponsors have discretion over, of course, within certain parameters of investments, but really investors going into the fund don't always know which investments the fund is going to acquire. We've been hearing a lot more about investors being focused on potentially doing deal-by-deal funds where once there's an asset that's identified, investors are then coming into those deal-by-deal funds. Again, so three different models, three different types of funds. And Josh, I'll answer with you. I have an initial question. How do these three types of models or structures compare from a tax perspective?
Josh De Sisto:
Yeah, happy to. Thanks, Michael. And good morning everybody on the West Coast and afternoon for everyone on the other side. Yeah, great point. And just to start off with a baseline, in these typical or standard structures, they're usually set up as partnerships and we'll get into later on how some other structuring comes into play. So the fund isn't going to pay or incur tax itself. It'll pass along to the investors items of income, expense, gain and loss items, and so they'll be similar in nature on that front. On the close-ended fund, as Michael mentioned, these have defined terms. So there's committed capital, there's a known life. There may or may not be extensions built into the agreement, but at least there's a quantifiable life term. On the evergreen side, there is an ongoing or open-ended fund, continuous capital coming in. There's more flexibility to launch into new deals from that perspective.
And a quick comparison on those first two is the allocations and the carried interest or promote, we'll use it interchangeably. It's much more simple on the close-ended fund. There's a known quantifiable capital.
The deals are known. And so upon exit, you can simplify that from that perspective. On the evergreen fund, it's a little bit more complicated. There's a little bit more accounting with investors coming in and out. So there's some revaluations, and not to get too into the weeds, but the redemption features are looked at or reviewed under the publicly traded partnership rules. So again, beyond the scope of this, but just something as a consistent item you'll hear throughout the webinar is that there should be a lot of upfront review of redemption terms, documents, and planning before these deals are structured. And then the deal by deal, it's a little bit more simple in terms of, again, the allocations are just siloed to that one deal. The promote and the carry are respective to that one deal. The only additional nuance would be the compliance requirements because there'd be more partnership filings, more K-1s to the investors, more state reporting, things of that nature.
Michael Torhan:
Great. Thanks, Josh. And the audience, you'll find a lot of these slides are intertwined throughout the session. We just talked about three different types of funds. Now we're going to talk about knowing who your investors are or who your future investors may be. Obviously, investor appetite for certain types of models will impact the structure. So these steps that we're going through, they're probably not meant to be looked at in chronological order, but more so as one kind of holistic view when you're launching a fund. And this slide, we'll talk a little bit about the investors that you anticipate having in the fund. When we talk to clients or new prospective clients or anybody looking to launch a fund, one of the first questions we always ask is who are you planning to fundraise from? Who are your investors going to be? Whether you're bringing in US taxable investors or tax exempt investors like pensions and IRAs and endowments or even foreign investors, a lot of those decisions or I guess a lot of those allocations of capital to your fund are really going to drive your structure.
And so Pan, a question I have for you is why does investor mix matter so much as to how a fund is structured?
Xiaobin Pan:
Yeah, thank you, Michael. So definitely a few points here is we're definitely trying to raise the money from the investors and all of different investors is going to have different tax needs. And when we kind of structuring a fund, we really want to make sure the fund is going to be structured in a way that is going to satisfy our investor needs. So in general, we kind of separate their investor into three broad categories, which is US taxable investors, tax exam investors and foreign investors. US taxable investors normally prefer pass through treatments, long-term capital gain character and legal phenter income. But in the meantime, because the income is flowing to the investor, they also have concerns on the complex state filing issue if the fund is having multi-state investments. Then it goes to a tax exam investors. They have major concerns on minimizing their unrelated business taxable income.
So they are generally exempt from the federal income tax, but if there's UBTI, which is mentioned that if there's UBTI flowing to them, they are probably going to be subject to tax in that case. Then foreign investor have their concern as well is because when they have ECI flowing to them, they probably need to pay tax on ECI and they probably need to file US income tax return because of the income flowing to them. So different kind of tax investor is going to have different tax needs and they probably want a special structure set up so that for tax exam in Wester, it probably blocks their UBTI and foreign Wester, it probably blocks minimize their US filing requirements. So kind of go into a little bit deeper on why tax exam Wester care or why foreign investor is going to have concerns on those is, as I mentioned earlier, tax exempt normally are exempt from federal income tax, but if you have UBTI flowing in, then they might be subject to tax.
For real estate funds purposes, normally real estate fund will generate rental income. So in general, rental income is exempt or excluded from UBTI, so you don't need to pay tax on that. However, if the property is going to be financed, it's going to be financed, then a portion of the income will be UBTI, which is going to be subject to tax maybe in some cases. So we have a basic simple example here is if a pension is going to receive 500,000 income from the fund and the funds property are like 60% financed with that. So which means that including this 500,000, 60% of this is UBTI, which means that 300,000 of this income is going to be taxable and the remaining 200,000 is not taxable. So it gives you a sense of why the tax exempt partner is going to care about whether the UBTI is going to flow to them.
Then it goes to foreign investor that foreign investor major concerns is going to be on the ECI and the tab. So ECI is basically effective connective income that is basically if you flow the income from the US business to them. So they are foreign investor. They probably don't want to file US income tax. So they are like, "If you are getting me a US business income, should I pay tax on that? Should I file a US return? If this is going to have a lot of business in different state, should I file on a state return?" So a lot of those concerns there is going to make them hesitated in funding the funds. They also have concerns on the front side is basically foreign investment in real estate property tax at, and that ad is going to basically require the foreign investor to pay tax on the gain from US real estate disposition with a withholding requirement.
So all of this requirement is going to make them hesitated on whether they want to make distribution, like contribution on the funds.
Michael Torhan:
Great. Thank you, Pan. Yeah, I think those are great terms. I think as accountants, we have hundreds of acronyms and sometimes we throw those acronyms around and expect everybody to know what they are. I think those three acronyms, I think anybody who's operating in the fund space, even if you're not an accountant, if you're in investment management, if you're in fundraising, I think those acronyms will come up. We always hear from clients that they mention that they're hearing investors talk about UBTI, ECI, FERPA. I think those three acronyms are important to know probably for everyone. So thanks for that, Paul. So we've talked about different types of structures in terms of the economics. We've talked a little bit about who the investors might be. Let's get a little bit deeper into the details now about what are the types of structures, right? We've kind of laid out a few structures here of how you can accommodate different types of investors and what are the pros and cons of each.
So Josh, you want to talk a little about these three different types of structures as well. We're going to talk about, I think, blockers and REITs and talk about who benefits from a simple structure and why may managers think about blockers or REITs as well and how do they work?
Josh De Sisto:
Yeah, absolutely. So I'll thumb through the three structures in a brief update on some of the benefits and risks, and then I'll probably spend a little bit more time on the blockers and the REITs just for a little bit more of the maybe not frequently as seen items. So to Michael's point, the structure one, this is the basic flow through. You've got a fund that has underlying deals, you've got your investors coming in, your manager, sponsor, GP. So this is pretty, I say, cookie cutter basic fund structure. There's one layer of tax. Everything flows, as we mentioned, all the activity flows out to the investors on their Schedule K1s, but you do run into those same issues that we just mentioned, the ECI, UBTI type issues. So again, there's some planning considerations to keep in mind here, and this will be with respect to all of them, phantom income, which we'll get into later, tax distributions, and just again, to just keep reiterating the need to have these discussions and these modeling and plans and ask questions upfront as these structurings happen.
Moving on to the second one. So just again, we'll be saying the word blocker a lot. I'm sure most everybody knows, but just this is essentially C corporation. So we'll use that interchangeably. The blocker in the sense could be implemented as a investor in the fund. So in the example, the flow chart on the left, this is kind of modeling out how foreign investors can come through a feeder partnership. So that could be an onshore feeder or an offshore feeder. We do see both. They come in through the blocker and then the blocker invests in the fund directly and it essentially helps reduce some of the tax filing burden. Again, the blocker blocks some of these UBTI, ECI issues, state issues, things like that. It also allows for some anonymity with the foreign investors in this specific situation, simplifies their tax filings if there are any.
So this is, I think, a very commonly seen structure.
And then on the REIT side, this has probably been more prevalent over the last, I think, five, six years as the 199A or the qualified REIT dividend deduction has come into play. And now with it being permanent has still gained quite a considerable amount of traction. In this example, you've got the REIT that sits below the fund and REIT's a very nuanced vehicle. It's basically a hybrid. It's a corporation at its core, but it does have flow through attributes depending on if the distributions are made. And so there's no entity level tax. Again, you get that flow through treatment. It's still going to act as have those blocker characteristics, blocking some of the state ECI, UBTI issues, things like that. And it just does come with another layer. There's always trade offs. The risks are, there's a lot more scrutiny on the filing requirements, testing requirements, both quarterly, annually, things of that nature, the type of income, we'll call it good income or bad income.
So there's ways to structure around that. And just high level, sticking on the latter two blockers, just I'll back up one slide. Note that the C corporation, this example, is still subject to 21% tax. We'll get into how you can maybe mitigate some of the tax expense there, but that's still going to be a consideration when modeling out the tax burden and for cashflow purposes. And as mentioned on the REIT side, you've just got a lot more, I say compliance, but responsibilities to make sure that the REIT is in compliance with all its income, asset, and investor makeup, distribution testing as well. And I think it all, again, it comes back to which one would you implement? I think it goes back at the core of it. It's circling back to that core investor group, know who your investors are, who's looking at what type of investment through what vehicle, what matters to them most.
And note that we do see there's always typically anchor investors or those larger investors that drive some of the decisions, but these should all be taken into consideration with respect to the structuring upfront.
Michael Torhan:
Thanks, Josh. There's two quick questions that just came in that I guess I'll just jump in to address them. There was one question on, can one blocker work for all foreign investors? And there's some follow-on question about whether the location of the foreign investor or tax treaties matters. I think that's a really good question because when blockers make distributions, remember a blocker is a C corporation, if you're just talking about the standard blocker, when it's making distributions out to investors, a typical distribution may be dividends. And again, there's planning to be done. We'll talk a little bit more about leverage blockers and potentially liquidating distributions, but your general distribution to a foreign investor can potentially be a dividend to that foreign investor, which itself can have withholding on it. So the blocker's paying tax at, let's call it 21%. And then if there's another 30% on the withholding on the dividend going out, well, now you're talking about a lot of tax, so you're creating a really big tax drag on the income to that investor.
So I think to that question, I think it's really important to understand where the foreign investors are and see what tax treaties are available to mitigate some of that withholding tax. Also thinking about the leverage blocker, which again, we'll actually talk about on the next slide, but hopefully that kind of answered that question. But yes, generally there's a blocker set up and all the foreign investors are coming in there, but each specific investor may be impacted differently based on their underlying nationality.
And then the other question that came in was, do we ever see a blocker used for state tax purposes for US taxable investors? I think that's a really good question as well, because if you have a fund that's in 30 or 40 states, there's a very big administrative burden on each investor. If I was an investor in that kind of fund, I'm now filing a personal return potentially in 30, 40 states, which is going to get really expensive really fast. So in particular, we've seen this in the REIT structure, and we probably don't have enough time on this webinar to go deep into the details as to how a REIT works, for example. But like Josh mentioned, a REIT generally does not pay tax at the REIT level, and then the shareholders will get REIT dividends. Oftentimes you may think, well, US taxable investors may not like that because there's no flow through of losses.
Everybody loves depreciation and losses in real estate. We'll talk about that a little bit later. In a REIT or any kind of blocker, your investors are not getting those losses. Well, if your investors are all passive and they're not using those losses anyway, they may prefer the REIT anyways because they don't have to follow those 30 states. A REIT is just generating a 1099 to the investors at the end of the day. Or if there's a feeder partnership, the K1's not going to have much on there other than potentially dividend income, maybe some portfolio expenses. You really are eliminating a lot of state filings for each investor. So I think the short answer to that question is yes, in that US taxable investors sometimes do like a REIT so that they don't have to deal with 30 state filings, which can get very expensive.
So on the point of blockers, I talked a little bit just now about if there's distributions being made out of blocker, are you paying a lot more tax because of a blocker structure? Like I said, there's 21% inside the blocker that's potentially withholding on the dividends going out to investors. And we had on the slide, and Josh brought up a little bit, the concept of shareholder loans. And so there is this concept of a leverage blocker. So Josh, do you want to expand a little bit more on that concept and why does sponsors somebody set up a blocker that's funded with both debt and equity?
Josh De Sisto:
Yeah, thanks. Great point. And I think a great question knowing that I think the initial question is why put another entity in the structure when you've got this extra layer of tax? And I think this example we'll go through shows how some of that tax drag, to Michael's point, can get reduced. And there's another concept that will layer on top of this with respect to these feeder blocker structures on how it can be a benefit on the foreign investor side as well. But just looking at the example, if it was just a straightforward equity came in, we'll use a thousand dollars in this example with no debt equity split, all equity, and the blocker subsequently has $100 of income, it's going to pay tax on that $100 at 21%, so $21 of tax. Fast-forward, if alternatively, the thousand dollars came into the blocker with a debt equity split, so part loan, part equity, you could see as $600 at a 60 / 40 split in this example.
At 10%, you'd have the interest expense of $40 to reduce your taxable income, thus leaving your net blocker tax at $8. So there's a pretty significant tax savings there by structuring it through debt and equity. And this is pretty nuanced as well. There's not a bright line test for that debt equity split. This again, goes into that planning. Transfer pricing studies are probably important in situations like this to be able to support what that debt equity split looks like. And again, adding support upfront to the files is advisable to avoid running into any hiccups later down the road on how you got to that split. I think 60 / 40, one thirds, two thirds, 70 / 30 is common. But again, there could be different attributes depending on where the assets are, where the investment is, the age, things like that. Those transfer pricing studies are quite helpful.
And one other point to mention here is there's a portfolio interest exemption provision that can be used in a structure like this where if the loan, the debt part is set up properly, meaning it's in registered form, it's non-contingent, it's a portfolio, not an active trade or business type lending entity, that those interest payments, so in this example, that $40 of interest expense that was incurred at the blocker, if that was also paid to the offshore members, if everything falls under the portfolio interest exemption, that $40 would not be subject to withholding, which is also a very advantageous result limiting not having to withhold for the payments, the cash to the investors and just the compliance side of things. So the quarterly foreign withholding requirements throughout the year. So very positive note there.
Michael Torhan:
Yeah, a big question. Oh, I guess we have poll number two. We can launch that. Yeah, this is yes and no, and then we'll give you five seconds just to make sure it launches, but we'll keep proceeding with the presentation. [Poll #2]. I think a big question that sometimes comes up when we're speaking with funds that are structuring and there's a question of, do I set up a blocker in the beginning? Do I set up a REIT at the beginning? As you see, these things can get very complex very fast. I mean, we're just trying to give a general overview. And as you see, it's already really complicated, even in the most simplistic terms. So oftentimes what we'll see is clients will make sure they work into their agreements, the ability to set up a secret blocker or the ability to set up a REIT just to be ready for those questions or for those investors that come and ask, "Do you have a UBTI blocker?" Like we mentioned, that's a tax exempt.
Do you have an ECI blocker?
But the process of going through and launching one of these, I mean, the simple secret blocker is probably a little bit less costly, but a REIT certainly can get very costly very quickly. And the administration of these and the tax compliance, oftentimes they'll generally be investors that will drive that decision making indirectly. But what's important is that as you're launching the fund to Keep that flexibility open and be knowledgeable about the structures. And so we've talked a little bit about, part one was the structuring and the startup of a fund. We've talked about the different types of funds, closed-ended, open-ended. We've talked about who the investors may be as well as some of the structures, just the typical pass through or the blockers and REITs. So now we're going to talk a little bit about, well, what happens once your fund is launched and you're operating the funds.
So typically funds can go anywhere from five, six, seven years, all the way up to 10, 11, 12 and longer. So there's a big time period from launch to wind down at some point where there's issues that come up as you're operating the fund. And so we're going to walk through what are some of the key issues that come up with taxes and how could they impact you throughout the life of the fund? And these are all things that, again, and I mentioned operating the fund, these are things that everybody needs to think about from day one as well. Because although some of these issues, like we talk about the waterfalls, phantom income later, depreciation, you may not see this in your fund for a couple of years after launch, but certainly you should be thinking about this from day one. And so the first topic here is waterfalls.
So this is effectively, how's the cash going to be divided between the LPs, the limited partners in your fund and the general partner?
Sometimes people talk about the 220 split. So one of the sources of compensation for the sponsor, the manager is a manager fee. That's often 2% or something that's a little bit less based off of investors coming in early into a fund or investors committing a certain amount of capital. They'll pay a little bit less than that. So that's the 2%. That's really what keeps the lights on for the manager. The other part of that 220 is the carried interest. So the carried interest, again, 20% is thrown out there a lot. That can vary from fund to fund, but that's effectively the interest that the manager and the general partner has in the future upside of the fund. And so there's different ways that funds get structured. And the two main ways are there's an American waterfall and a European waterfall. And again, the American waterfall is a deal by deal waterfall where the manager may get that 20% carried interest deal by deal.
So if you have a deal that sells for a large profit, the manager only subordinated to the investor capital for that specific deal.
So if the investors put in a hundred million dollars, but they only put in five million for that deal, well, the GP gets to share in that carried interest once those LPs get the five million back and potentially some preferred return. Again, there's different types of economics that are written into these deals, but again, it's just a five million there and the preferred and then the GP gets to start sharing. The European waterfall, which is the whole fund waterfall, the GP typically does not share in that 20%, that future upside until the investors have gotten all of their hundred million back plus the preferred return on that entire hundred million. So clearly in the American waterfall, the GP has the potential to get carried interest earlier versus the European, but there's different nuances on each and we'll talk a little bit about those. And so Pan, do you want to speak a little bit about how do these two compare, particularly from a tax perspective?
Xiaobin Pan:
So from the tax perspective, the biggest difference between American fund model, which is deal by deal and European is basically the differences on when the GP is going to receive the carries. So deal by deal, we have a really simple example here showing the timing of when the GP is going to receive their carries. We are not going to go into a 2D of how the return of capital is going to make, how the preferred is going to allocate, but basically the example here is going to focus on the timing of the carry distributed. The example here we basically have, so the fund is going to have two 10 million deals. The manager is going to have 20% carry. DOA earns $4 million of income. DOB is going to have $2 million of loss. So under American waterfall is basically the manager is having ability to get their carry when each investment is going to be sold.
So when DOA is sold, the manager is able to get 20% of four million income, which is 0.8 carries. But it turns out that when the DOB is sold, then the overall income is only two million. So that inventory the manager is only entitled to $2 million of 20% and therefore the manager would need to return a zero four point median back to the fund. Now in the other way, European is basically wait until deal A and DOB are both sold. So inventory we have $2 million of income and then $0.4 million of carry is going to be distributed to managers. So the key differences here is really how the manager is going to receive their carry. The American style is going to give the manager an opportunity to get the carry first, but instead European is going to wait until we know how the fund's overall performance is going to be and wait until Investor gets all their cash back, like return of capital, preferred returns, and then managers start to get the carries.
Michael Torhan:
There's a big tax consideration when you're thinking about the American versus European waterfall, and that's cash that's being distributed potentially to the GP without income or income that's being allocated to the GP without the cash. We've seen cases in the European waterfall where the GP's not entitled to cash till the end, not to the end of the fund, but till the end of the waterfall. I mean, think about that scenario where you have a hundred million dollars of capital, you have one deal that sells for a large amount of income upfront. The GP is very far away in terms of getting cash. Obviously the first deal may not have enough proceeds to pay back all the invested capital. So the GP is not entitled to cash upfront, but they may very well be allocated income from that sale. And that's what we call phantom income, which we'll talk about in a second.
On the American waterfall, which is deal by deal, the GP may be entitled to cash within the fund because that first deal generated the cash. The income allocated though to the GP may not be sufficient because of a clawback. So the clawback that Pam just mentioned, if the deal doesn't generate enough income in the long term, the GP may have to put money in. And the way allocations work for tax purposes, there may not be enough income to go to the GP. And there's some very technical issues, again, outside of the scope of this webinar, but those distributions may create gain on the outside of the fund. They may be covered by liability. So very technical kind of concepts, which we're not going to go through here, but these are concepts that you should be thinking about asking your law firm, your accounting firm to really have these discussions as you're working on the fund to understand.
And so here we have the phantom income, I mentioned depreciation and state taxes. So here are some three pain points and issues that we see come up from time to time during the operations of a fund. And so Josh and Pan, I'll ask each of you to touch on one of these. So Josh, Pan, you want to start on the Phantom income?
Xiaobin Pan:
Sure. So Michael mentioned that earlier already. It's basically that when the investor is allocated income but the cash is not distributed, there are a few easy example here is if the fund is holding a few properties and then one of the property is sold for a million dollars. So they probably use this medium dollars to buy for another property. So in this case, in the gain is going to be allocated to the investors, but the investor is not going to receive cash. So in another way, it might happen to manager as well is the fund overall is doing a great job, is making monies. However, the cash flow is not enough to cover all investors return of capital preferred returns. Therefore, the manager is going to be allocate income, but the manager is not going to receive the carry yet. So in this case, we normally have plannings on the Fanta income as well during operating the funds.
There were two common approach there. One is the tax distribution. We kind of let the investor know that, "Hey, you are going to be allocating the income this year. Here's no cash that we going to be distributed to you to make the tax estimate payments." So the other one is they probably don't have enough cash to distribute to the investor to make their estimate payments. So what they would normally do is basically let the investor know that you are going to have income this year. Please make sure that you plan your estimate tax payment ahead while you're filing your tax returns or while you are doing the year plannings, things like that. I'm going to pass it to George to talk a bit about the depreciations while we kind of operating the funds as well.
Josh De Sisto:
Yeah, thanks Pan. And I'll run through this one pretty quick. We got a really great example in a slide or two, but just some things to know about and to plan for again, I think that's the common theme here. Cost segregations are important, have been pretty popular. We've been dealing with those a lot lately, especially with the bonus depreciation being back on the table at 100%. So just to be aware, it's a timing difference and taking the upside on the front, but knowing that there's going to be some recapture, some planning and some modeling to be looked at for the exit or the disposition of those assets.
And then again, I think we mentioned this before, but those losses are fantastic, but a lot of times in a traditional fund, we might see some of those passive losses suspended due to the passive activity rules. Again, it's probably another webinar in itself. They don't go away, but they may be sit at the investor's tax return until they either get future passive income from the deal or the deal winds up and exits in which those passive losses will be freed up 100%. And as you can imagine on the blocker and REIT side, those losses and that depreciation is typically just reducing the taxable income for those respective entities. So again, they don't get passed out to the investors that sit above those respective entities types, but they are being used to offset current year income. Pan, you want to jump to states?
Xiaobin Pan:
Yeah, state is always my favorite. So I normally think about state tax in two levels. One is the fund level. So basically wherever the fund owns the property or operates in a business is going to be subject to state filings. So if a larger fund is going to buy 20, 30 property in different state, then the fund might be subject to filing state filing for 2030 state. And all of the state is going to have different filing requirement, not just saying like, "Oh, you have to file income taxes. Sometimes the state have city filing as well. You probably have franchise tax as well, like LLC tax. You probably have some of this personal property taxes, filing requirement, things like that. So state is going to be a really complex topic here. We are not going to cover too much as we don't have enough time for all those topics.
However, even though we are kind of just saying that we are filing the state tax return because we own the property in the state, the fund might still be subject to filing if you don't own the property. So for example, New York, if you have a California fund that is having New York state residence, and so the New York state says that I don't care if you have business operate in New York, if you have New York State residence partner in your fund, I want you to file a new estate return. So it's not just in the New York state that is having this filing requirement. A lot of those other states having the filing residency filing requirement as well. So all of those things that we'll need to plan ahead before we incorporate in the fund, before we buy the property or even though when we doing the fundraising and then consider who is going to be our investors.
Then the other part is going to be how is the investor is going to file their returns? If the fund is going to file 2030 state, normally the investor gets flow through incomes from the fund, then the investor might need to file 2030 state and the fund might be obligate to prepare estimate tax and that and the investor know how much is your taxable income, how much is your state taxable income? And that then know their share of income for the taxable year or a physical or calendar year so that they can plan ahead their tax for the year.
Michael Torhan:
Great. Thanks Pan and Josh. I think two more points on I think those great issues that were mentioned. Number one on the phantom income. In addition to investors having phantom income, like I mentioned, sometimes the GP will have phantom income from carried interest. It was allocated income for, but no cash. Really important to make sure you have good tax distribution provisions in your operating agreements. Again, so that kind of ties back again, what's going to happen in four or five years. You want to make sure you're thinking about that on day one. On the depreciation, again, like Josh said, we all love losses. We all love bonus depreciation. Making sure you understand who your investors are and whether they're going to use those losses is an important concept to think through as well. There are certain states like New York where take me, for example, I'm an accountant.
If I get a large K-1 with a large loss, I may not be able to use it. Like Josh mentioned, it gets suspended and carried forward. New York still makes you adjust back for that bonus depreciation. So there may be some timing issues there with state add back. So again, we have been seeing more and more funds do cost sig studies, especially 100% bonus. Our call seg team here gets a lot of requests for those cost segs, but we are having those conversations all the time with our clients to make sure that there's no unintended consequences.
One last point on operating a fund, K-1 timing. Again, I think after investors are earning a nice return on any investment, the second biggest concern is getting the K-1s on time. We always like to make sure there's a detailed calendar, there's expectations set early in the year as to what are the deliverable deadlines going to be and when are investors going to be getting the K-1s. Anybody who's kind of worked with investors in the past will know the K-1s are super important for their own personal returns. Josh, you want to spend a minute or so on the overall timeline?
Josh De Sisto:
Yeah, I'll go through this one pretty quickly just so we can get to the last couple of slides here. But I think it's just great points, Michael, and I think the crux of this one is just it's communication and expectations, having those set. Sometimes we do see that the delivery dates are outlined in the LPA or the subscription documents or those messages are given to the investors as they come in. So they already have set expectations. And absent that, it's just important to understand, again, what they're expecting, what the timing is. If it's not practical to get a final K-1 by March 15th or April 15th by the time they're going to pay their estimated taxes is to make a plan for an estimate. Is an estimate possible? Is it reasonable to have one out there or is it not? And if final K-1s come out, what's the timing?
I know June 30th is a big kind of date on final K-1s coming out, whether if audits are still going on, all these things push the delivery back waiting on lower tier K-1s from other tax providers, things like that. So I think it just comes down, again, part of that planning checklist is managing expectations and having the communication more frequent than not.
Michael Torhan:
So here's our third polling question. [Poll #3]. Just give that five seconds to appear on your screen and then we'll continue with the slides. You should be able to still answer as they proceed. So now we're going to go into our final segment of the webinar and that's winding down the fund. So we've spoken about what are the key points on launching a fund. We've talked about a couple of the operating issues that come up throughout the life of a fund. Now we'll walk through a couple of slides as to what are some of the key issues that come up when you're winding down the fund or even when you're selling off assets throughout the life of a fund when you're winding down certain investments, what are the key things that come up and that everybody should be mindful of?
And the first one is actually really on sales, whether it's sales or at the end of a fund's life of assets or even midway through a fund, what are the big issues that come up with selling? And the big one is depreciation. Losses have been taken throughout the years and that does get recaptured, whether that's capital gains or their income, there is a recapture. Depreciation is just timing at the end of the day.
So Josh, do you want to speak a little bit about what happens to that depreciation when the property is sold? And again, whether it's halfway or at the end of a fund's life, how does it look?
Josh De Sisto:
Yeah, absolutely. And again, and I'll run through this one quickly. I know there's a lot of numbers on here, but I think the gist of it is if those considerations on, again, all those great deductions that were taken in early years with bonus and depreciation on the property, when it comes to the exit that it's really easy to say, I've got X gain, I got X cash, how much I put in. So it's long-term capital gain. Let's just say it's my tax, I'm going to earmark 20% tax. But what that effectively is leaving out is the recapture on the depreciation items. So there's two pieces. Again, I think this is a fantastic topic and probably another full webinar plus on 1245 property that it would be subject to 37% rates. And that's kind of your PP&E, your five, seven, shorter life type assets. Your building, whether it's 27 and a half or 39 years, that depreciation on 1250 property, so unrecaptured 1250, would be subject to a little bit more of a preferred rate right at 25% in this example, 250,000.
And then the balance of that gain, so in this example, five and a half million dollar gain, the remaining three would be at the "long-term capital gain rate." So when you blend all that, you effectively get a 25.5% rate as opposed to if you just blanketed it at 20%, I think you'd fall short 300,000 if you were just trying to do a back of the envelope without knowing the significance of the recapture piece. And one other quick note, just again for planning purposes, this example ignores state income tax, depending on what state it could be zero or it could be something significant, California, New York, nine, 10, 11%. And then also the net investment income tax of 3.8 would be tacked on to the long-term capital gain portion. So the numbers tick up there quickly, if not planned ahead of time.
Michael Torhan:
Thanks, Josh. We talked a little bit about GP true-ups and clawbacks early on, particularly in really in either of the waterfalls. In the American waterfall, which is deal by deal, if a GP is paid out large carried interest payment from deal one, but the fund doesn't do as great in the subsequent deals, it does great, but that first deal was just such a home run, there may be a clawback similarly on the European waterfall. If there's some carried interest paid out halfway through the fund, but there's one asset at the end that loses money, that could be a clawback. Pam, can you talk a little bit more about how are those typically managed and what are the details more on the clawback?
Xiaobin Pan:
Yeah, definitely. So we basically covered bundle waterfall calculation earlier. It's similar to what we talked about before. It's kind of you are getting a million off carry and then it turns out based on the final calculation, you probably are only entitled to 0.6 million. So you'll need to pay a 0.4 million clawback to the fund. So it happens too. So when we are winding down the funds, this kind of apply to all this waterfall. So it really depends on how much carry it has been allocated to the manager and depending on how much the final calculation is going to be, and then you see whether the manager is overpaid or underpaid, you just pay them the many differences or getting the money back. So the risk here is normally when you overpay the manager, and in many cases the manager would already paying the tax on the carry that is allocate to them already.
So let's say the manager here is going to be allocate a million dollars of carry and then they actually get the money and then pays the tax on a million dollars. Let's say the tax rate is 20%, which is 200,000, but inventory they are only entitled to 0.6 million, so they are returning the 0.4 million back. What happened to return that money? They are not going to get the tax back. So there's a concern there when we are just operating or manage how the carry is going to be allocate when we are going to distribute the carries there because this is going to affect their tax pay as well. So in many cases, we are trying to prevent the money paying back, getting back money from the managers. So we somehow is going to possibly have escrow a hold back a portion of the carry if we are planned to make the distributions and then we probably have manager guarantees in during claw back tasks when we doing the carry distributions.
Michael Torhan:
Yeah, I think one key item here we have here on the screen and Pan was talking through, a clawback may not happen until year 12, year 14, year 15, if it ever does. Again, bringing that back to day one, the GP generally only has to put back the amount and got net of taxes, or that's typically how the tax distribution provisions are written in the agreements. It's really important to look at what that tax distribution provision says and what does that clawback provision say and really make sure you understand how that would work because there are different variations of those clawback provisions and you want to understand that when you're forming that entity and not get caught by surprise in year 13 or 14 as to what cash has to go back into the fund. So we have about three minutes left and we're just going to skip a couple slides.
There was one, we have a key takeaway slide we want to show everybody that summarizes all the topics we've spoken about. So I'm just going to skip ahead. Great. So here are the key takeaways and these kind of coincide with each of the big ticket items we spoke about today. And so Josh and Pam, I'll let each of you talk about a couple of these in summary.
Josh De Sisto:
Yeah, sure. Again, probably said it multiple times, I think can't stress it enough to try to model the exit before the entity or the structure's formed and those components come in and knowing the investor mix, taxable versus tax exempt versus foreign, the needs of each and what those underlying entities, whether it's blockers that have their own corporate tax or multiple entity listings take into account, decide on the blocker restructure, the parallel fund before that close. Things get expensive and/or potentially not possible to convert later down the life for the fund. So these things are important on the front end and just aligning the economics, the waterfall, the tax distribution provisions, things like that, state filing compliance, just understanding on who's the intended recipient for the fund structure.
Xiaobin Pan:
Yeah. So when we model the asset, here's the fourth polling question that you can edit here, just give you a few seconds to answer the question. [Poll #4]. So however, I think today's session is basically covered. The main issue or concern here is basically how we are going to plan ahead. So we have all this topic that we talk about. We know about investors align with the economics. We want to know what kind of recapture we are going to have when we sell the property. Is there any cloud bad? Do we want to put in the cloud bad protections in the operating agreement so that it doesn't surprise the manager when the money needs to be returned back to the fund? So really important key here, we always want to plan ahead. The earlier we can identify the potential issues, the more option we have to address that.
So always consult with tax advisory when it's needed. So just before the decision was finally made.
Michael Torhan:
Great. Thanks, Pan. Thanks, Josh. I'll just give it back to Bella for some final items.
Transcribed by Rev.com AI
What's on Your Mind?
Start a conversation with the team