Compliance and Regulatory Services ('CARS') Hot Topics for March 2016
March 09, 2016
For this month, we thought we would mention a critical area of compliance that is often discussed by regulated entities, such as investment advisers, broker/dealers, and NFA registered members regarding how best to implement the difficult to define concept of a culture of compliance. The SEC, FINRA, CFTC all speak about the requirement of registrants to develop a strong tone at the top, or culture of compliance, which starts at the top of a firm and extends down to all levels and all employees. A culture of compliance is developed over time through on-going communication and education. The culture is enhanced through the inculcation of the critical components of the regulated entities compliance requirements into employees job responsibilities, based on the particular employee’s role within the organization, and the associated level of regulatory risk that role presents.
What have we seen?
We have seen many of our clients take on this difficult task. They find it daunting because of the time consuming process of introducing and educating employees on what takes compliance professional years to learn themselves. However, the one approach we have seen that has generated a level of enthusiasm at one investment advisory client that is registered with the SEC, FINRA and the NFA, is to incentivize employees who take on the initiative of understanding the compliance procedures applicable to their specific job function and not just go through the mechanical motions of what the compliance officer has recommend be done to comply with firm procedures. They do this through the creative use of performance evaluations where the evaluation contains a section dedicated to compliance. The compliance section of the evaluation receives a weighting that impacts the employees overall evaluation that impacts compensation. Those employees who score high are monetarily rewarded, while a low compliance ranking can have the effect of reducing anticipated compensation.
This approach also works well with current SEC thinking since it demonstrates the right tone at the top and correspondingly reduces senior management risk of failing to implement steps to develop a culture of compliance. It is also consistent with the theme of the Dodd Frank Wall Street Reform Act of impacting compensation based on performance.
What are the risks?
We are seeing more and more claims by regulators of registrants failing to develop a culture of compliance when routine inspections uncover compliance failures. In the past, it has been the SEC who has primarily made these claims that result in harsher action against the registrant. However, we are now seeing FINRA take on a similar tact. As part of a sweep review, FINRA has recently published a notice that they will meet with senior management, including compliance and legal, to determine how the firm has established the right compliance culture. In the notice, FINRA outlined eight items they will be interested in during sweep interviews. We note that one of the items is compensation. Establishing Communicating and Implementing Cultural Values.
Our Take: Previously FINRA-registered broker dealers were able to escape the claim of not fostering a strong culture of compliance since that objective was more suited for registered investment advisers who are subject to a fiduciary standard. It appears as though those unwritten walls have come down even though brokers are not yet subject to a fiduciary standard. FINRA seems to be moving closer to the SEC, both functionally and stylistically, in its examination of brokers.
|Feb. 19, 2016||Chairman’s Address at SEC Speaks - “Beyond Disclosure at the SEC in 2016”|
|Feb.19,2016||Remarks atthe “SEC Speaks” Conference: What Lies Ahead? The SEC in 2016|
|Feb.19, 2016||The Falling Leaves of the Buttonwood Tree|
|Jan. 25, 2016||Directors Forum 2016 Keynote Address|
|Jan. 21, 2016||International Developments – Past, Present and Future|
(Complete Listing: http://www.finra.org/Industry/Regulation/Notices/2014/index.htm)
FINRA Rule Filings List:
(Complete Listing: http://www.finra.org/Industry/Regulation/RuleFilings/2014/index.htm)