ESG Investing

September 20, 2022

In this episode of Engaging Alternatives Spotlight, Elana Margulies-Snyderman, Director, Publications, EisnerAmper, speaks with Ima Edomwonyi, Executive & Senior ESG Analyst at Franklin Mutual Advisers. He shares his outlook for ESG including the greatest opportunities and challenges, how the firm integrates it and more.


Transcript

Elana Margulies-Snyderman:Hello, and welcome to the EisnerAmper podcast series. I'm your host, Elana Margulies-Snyderman. And with me today is Ima Edomwonyi, Executive and Senior ESG Analyst at Franklin Mutual Advisors based in Short Hills, New Jersey. Today, Ima will share with us his outlook for ESG, including the greatest opportunities and challenges, how the firm integrates it and more. Hi, Ima, thanks for being with me today.
Ima Edomwonyi:Thanks for having me, Elana. It's wonderful to be here.

EMS:
Absolutely. So Ima, tell us a little about how you got to where you are today and what you do at Franklin Mutual Advisors.
IE:Yeah, absolutely. I started my career on the fixed income side of the business at Alliance Bernstein. At AB, I had some early exposure to impact and sustainability by way of a fund that eventually became their new impact fund. After some time, I got a great opportunity to work at Nippon Life Global Investors in Japan on the equity investment side, where we launched two different strategies, a ESG equity investing strategy, as well as a sustainable development goals fund. After business school, shout out to Columbia Business School, I joined Franklin Mutual a little over a year ago to co-lead our efforts around ESG and sustainable investing. And my role at FMA was newly created. Initially, it was one part quantitative integration from an investment process perspective and then utilizing that to launch new investment strategies to be executed with a backbone of deep value equity investing. The world continues to expand, giving a lot of new ESG regulation, and it seems to be getting more complex every month, frankly.
EMS:So Ima, giving your focus on ESG, I wanted to start off by hearing what exactly is ESG investing, and what is your outlook for this space?
IE:Yeah, the million dollar question. Well, the work I do involves working closely with my chief investment officer, head of research, increasingly our head of product, to craft basically a top-down investment philosophy around ESG investing, while not deviating too materially from the deep value investment philosophy of the firm, just given the newness of many aspects of ESG today. More specifically, I think, through the application of ESG principle adverse indicators, which are relatively new, on portfolio construction, selection criteria for new investments, criteria for divestments, if at all. And increasingly, I'm spending much more time on understanding the different methods of carbon accounting on portfolio characteristics. I look at ESG investing really within the boundary of equity investing, as a method of research that combines financial and non-financial information on a company to have a fuller picture of the operations and the competitive position of that company.

In a sense, I think of ESG really as externality captured at the company level. I also believe ESG has an unstructured data problem from the perspective of a public money manager. From a company perspective, the climate risks are so distributed across the system it's historically been very hard for one specific company to have incentives to address a lot of these issues. But what's really happened over the last decade is that technology has created an environment where anything can be measured, and social media has created a level of transparency that was unimaginable until more recently. And it makes it increasingly pertinent that companies really have to look at these risks, as it's dangerous increasingly to not do so. In terms of outlook, I would say a few big buckets. It seems like every country or jurisdiction is going about their own sustainability regulation. As a result, I think ESG is going to become very regionalized over time.

I suspect that the ESG integration category or concept is going to fall by the wayside as we have more guardrails around what is an ESG fund or an impact fund or a climate fund, specifically. I also believe carbon accounting will become very, very important over the next five years in a way that was unimaginable previously. And I also think sustainability data over time will become very similar to financial data and released in a similar frequency. I think there are going to be a lot of variations in this space, and climate, for example, on its own is going to be a massive topic that specific funds will be on the market to address. So I know I covered quite a few things, but I think just in a nutshell, I think it's going to be a space that has a lot of innovation and looks markedly different when you look 5, 10 years on than it does today.
EMS:Yeah, Ima, absolutely. So I wanted to ask you to take a deeper dive into ESG, and what are some of the greatest opportunities you see and why?
IE:Yeah, it's kind of similar to some of the topics I just touched on. I think the unstructured data challenge within ESG was really underappreciated until very recently. The core ideas of a lot of this stuff aren't new, but the methods are increasingly regulated and actually does leave room for innovation within the asset management industry in a way you can't find in many other areas of finance. I think carbon accounting will become very important as people start trying to allocate emissions to specific entities and specific companies. Again, the methods are new, they're not straightforward, there's a lot to address, but I think there's going to be quite a bit of stakeholder pressure to get this done in a pretty speedy fashion. I also believe the impact and outcomes category will eventually grow to be a pretty large space as people look for impact strategies that have their values kind of baked into those things and have some kind of real world impact.

And then the last thing I would say is there's going to be a greater focus on adaptation. I don't think we're taking adaptation to a lot of these climate risks serious enough. But the conversations are starting to change. And I think as the trends continue to change, the conversations will continue to change. And you see that with something like water, which as a theme is going to become more and more important. And we're going to have to address some of the demand side issues of the equation, because a lot of ESG today tends to really look at the supply side of things and not really the demand side of things. And I think that's going to change as more people, more sophisticated eyes come into the space.
EMS:Oh, absolutely, Ima. So I wanted to shift gears a little bit and ask you what are some of the greatest challenges you face in this space and why?
IE:Again, although the ideas aren't new in the space, the packaging under the ESG umbrella term is relatively new for most people. It remains unfamiliar in the mainstream on the whole. That's changing over the last six months as it becomes more politicized. It also confuses investors. It's unregulated, underrated inside. And I think just generally, people continue to talk past each other. If I were to put it into three bullet points, some folks view ESG as a distraction and don't believe a lot of commitments are going to be met.

Some folks don't believe it's measurable and the aggregate scores have little meaning. And others believe that there's no relationship to financial performance. I think the most interesting thing about all this though is that despite all these challenges, companies seem to be spending more, not less time and resources to a lot of these ESG endeavors. And so I think no matter your viewpoint, ESG considerations are becoming more, not less important in companies' decision makings as the real world impacts continue to escalate.

And then I think the last thing I would say is the quality of ESG data and understanding the size of the market has been pretty difficult. The quality of data makes it very hard to structure these products across different asset classes or even within equities. It's a very different ballgame between large cap versus small or mid-cap just because of the data quality. It's the first inning, really, is kind of how I look at it on a lot of these ESG trends. And as more and more participants get into the space, as more clients demand products that have some of these traits, I would expect a lot of innovation in this space going forward.
EMS:Very exciting, everything that's going on. So Ima, I wanted to ask you more specifically, how does Franklin Mutual Advisors integrate it both at the macro level and via the fund level?
IE:Yeah, I think I'll talk about this more from how do funds just generally should think about more integration. A lot of ESG fund selection today is based on a concept called single materiality. And the idea behind that is that the impact of a changing world on a company's profit and losses are most important, not the reverse. And I think that concept is really at the heart of a lot of the miscommunication with ESG, is not really understanding that single or double materiality lens. I think over time what's going to happen as well is the sustainability preferences of clients will become more important, just given how bottoms up ESG has been from a driver's perspective. I think knowing the preferences of our clients will allow us to deliver solutions via SMAs that match preferences to a better degree than they do today. And I look at integration really at the fund level as a very systemic thing.

So I think it affects strategy, it affects capital allocation, and over time, companies will be able to provide better data around this that allows us at the fund level to get a fuller picture of companies' activities and be able to structure better products that our clients are actually looking for. But ultimately, I don't think there's a right way to really integrate ESG, is kind of what I'll say. I think what people are going to learn as they try to put out these strategies is that whatever asset class specific strategy you're running within that determines how you go about ESG and what aspects of it you decide to focus on. So again, I think just trying to integrate will lead to innovation that's tied to your core investment strategy.
EMS:Ima, we've covered a tremendous amount of ground today and I wanted to see if you have any final thoughts you would like to share with us.
IE:Yeah, I guess the last thing I'll say is that as ESG becomes talked about a lot, politicized, et cetera, that's normal. I think a lot of these concepts are new to the financial markets. There's going to be pushes and pulls as people figure out what this means for them and their strategy. But at the end of the day, I think ESG funds are simply products. They don't replace public regulation or private externalities. It's actually dependent on regulation for a lot of stuff to work over time. As a whole, I think we have a steep learning curve ahead with climate investing, with carbon accounting. We're really seeing a different way to analyze investments, and that's bringing in social and environmental externalities to our analysis. It's not a copy and paste or check box exercise. Investors, companies, regulators, even myself, we're all on a learning curve. And I think one thing that really excites me about this space is I feel like I learn new things pretty much every month, whether by force or not, just because it's just changing so much and there's so many things happening.

And one of the jokes I've made to myself is I think ESG is the fastest, slowest space out there because it seems like nothing is happening, but so much is happening simultaneously. But I guess I'll leave it on a personal note. I really look forward to the next generation of investors, whom I believe will have a more natural bias to this style of investing just given their lived experience. So I think it's an exciting space and there's going to be more to come. And thank you so much for having me on your podcast and giving me the opportunity to share my perspective.
EMS:Absolutely. Thank you so much for sharing your perspective with our listeners. And thank you for listening to the EisnerAmper podcast series. Visit eisneramper.com for more information on this and a host of other topics. And join us for our next EisnerAmper podcast when we get down to business.

Transcribed by Rev.com

About Elana Margulies-Snyderman

Elana Margulies-Snyderman is an investment industry reporter and writer who develops articles, opinion pieces and original research designed to help illuminate the most challenging issues confronting fund managers and executives.


More in This Series

Convexity Strategies
Convexity Strategies

In this episode of Engaging Alternatives Spotlight, Elana Margulies-Snyderman, Director, Publications, EisnerAmper, speaks with Nancy Davis, Chief Investment Officer of Quadratic Capital Management, a Greenwich, Connecticut-based investment advisory firm focused on convexity strategies.

Deep Tech Venture Capital Investing
Deep Tech Venture Capital Investing

In this episode of Engaging Alternatives Spotlight, Elana Margulies-Snyderman, Director, Publications, EisnerAmper, speaks with James Wang, General Partner, Creative Ventures, a deep tech venture firm investing in early-stage companies. He shares his outlook for VC investing in early-stage companies, including the greatest opportunities and challenges, how the firm is embracing DEI and more.

Emerging Markets Infrastructure Debt
Emerging Markets Infrastructure Debt

A discussion with Susan Wisialko, Founder and CIO of Global Infrastructure Finance, who shares her outlook for investing in emerging markets infrastructure debt, including the greatest opportunities and challenges, how the firm is integrating ESG, DEI and more.

Systematic Investing
Systematic Investing

A discussion on the outlook for systematic investing including the greatest opportunities and challenges, how the firm is integrating ESG, DEI and more.

Venture Capital Investing in Women-Owned Entrepreneurs
Venture Capital Investing in Women-Owned Entrepreneurs

In this episode of Engaging Alternatives Spotlight, Elana Margulies-Snyderman, Director, Publications, EisnerAmper, speaks with Victoria Pettibone, Chief Investment Officer & Managing Partner, Astia Fund, a Silicon Valley-based early-stage venture capital fund that invests in women entrepreneurs.

Private Credit
Private Credit

A discussion with with Danielle Brown, CEO, Altriarch Capital Management on her outlook for private credit, including the greatest opportunities and challenges, her experience being a woman investment manager in the industry, and how the firm is embracing DEI. 

Growth Equity Investing in Hospitality & Hospitality Tech
Growth Equity Investing in Hospitality & Hospitality Tech

In this episode of Engaging Alternatives Spotlight, Elana Margulies-Snyderman, Senior Manager, Publications, EisnerAmper, speaks with Mark Leavitt, Managing Partner & Co-Founder of Enlightened Hospitality Investments, a New York-based growth equity fund he co-founded with restauranteur Danny Meyer. He shares his outlook for investing in hospitality and hospitality tech including the greatest opportunities and challenges, how the firm is integrating ESG, DEI and more.

 Investing With Purpose
Investing With Purpose

The outlook for sustainable investing including the greatest opportunities and challenges, thoughts on the SEC’s rules to enhance ESG disclosures, how the firm is addressing DEI and more.

Investing With a Climate Lens
Investing With a Climate Lens

Zach Stein shares his outlook for investing in companies focused on addressing climate change, including the greatest opportunities and challenges, thoughts on the SEC’s push for more transparency, how the firm is integrating DEI and more.

Interval Funds
Interval Funds

Kim Flynn, Alternative Investments, XA Investments, shares her views on interval funds including the greatest opportunities and challenges, how the firm integrates ESG, the challenges of making private investments more accessible for every investor and more.

The “Social” Component of ESG Investing
The “Social” Component of ESG Investing

A discussion on the “S” or “Social” component of ESG investing, exclusively on economic inclusion and high-volume responsible lending to small businesses including but not limited to women, people of color, veteran-owned businesses and those in low income areas.

Systematic Global Macro Investing
Systematic Global Macro Investing

A discussion on the outlook for systematic global macro investing, including the greatest opportunities and challenges, yield investing, ESG and thoughts on the SEC’s push for enhanced transparency.

80/20 Rule for Investing
80/20 Rule for Investing

A discussion on the 80/20 rule and how it applies to investing, the SEC’s approach to 100% disclosure, DEI and more.

Water Investing
Water Investing

EisnerAmper speaks with Matt Diserio, President of Water Asset Management, a New York City and San Francisco-based investment manager deemed one of the first water industry investors investing exclusively in companies and assets that ensure water quality and supply.

ESG Real Estate Loans
ESG Real Estate Loans

A discussion with Chris Callahan, President & CEO of X-Caliber Capital about his views on investing in ESG-focused real estate loans, including the greatest opportunities and challenges in the space, what the firm is doing to champion DEI and more.

Crypto Hedge Fund Investing
Crypto Hedge Fund Investing

In this episode of Engaging Alternatives Spotlight, Elana Margulies-Snyderman speaks with Sadie Raney, Co-Founder and CEO at crypto hedge fund Strix Leviathan and Co-Founder at crypto robo advisor Makara.

ESG from a Risk Management and Investment Perspective
ESG from a Risk Management and Investment Perspective

A conversation with Patrick Ghali, Managing Partner of Sussex Partners, who shares his outlook for the alternative investment industry, including strategies he sees most attractive and ones that face the biggest challenges.

Capital Raising in a Hybrid World
Capital Raising in a Hybrid World

The outlook for capital raising in a mainly virtual world, how he pivoted during COVID-19, advice he has to successfully raise capital and finally, what he anticipates capital raising will be like post-COVID-19.

Equity Risk Management
Equity Risk Management

Ricardo Cortez, Co-CEO of Broadmark Asset Management, shares with us his background of how he got into investing, his outlook for the hedge fund industry, including the greatest opportunities and challenges, and how he is championing DEI on both a firm-level and throughout the alternative investments industry as a whole.

Outlook for the Fund of Hedge Fund Industry
Outlook for the Fund of Hedge Fund Industry

Elana Margulies-Snyderman speaks with Luis D’Amato, Partner and Portfolio Manager of Aston Capital Management. He shares his background of how he got into investing, his outlook for the fund of hedge fund industry.

Climate Change
Climate Change

In this episode of Engaging Alternatives Spotlight, Elana Margulies-Snyderman speaks with Tom Soto, Founder and Managing Partner of the Diverse Communities Impact Fund (DCIF), a Latino-owned lower middle market impact-focused private equity fund based in Los Angeles.

U.S. Lower Middle Market Investing
U.S. Lower Middle Market Investing

In this episode of Engaging Alternatives Spotlight, Elana Margulies-Snyderman speaks with Brett Hickey of Star Mountain Capital who shares his views on the U.S. lower middle market, and the various opportunities he sees in making direct investments.

Distressed Credit and Special Situations Opportunities
Distressed Credit and Special Situations Opportunities

In this episode, Cindy Chen Delano of Invictus Global Management shares her non-traditional path into money management, her outlook on alternative investments with respect to distressed credit and special situations, her experience being a woman money manager, what she is doing to encourage more women to go into investing, and how the firm is embracing D&I.

Multi-Strategy Hedge Fund and Opportunistic Credit Investing
Multi-Strategy Hedge Fund and Opportunistic Credit Investing

Elana Margulies-Snyderman speaks with Tracy McHale Stuart, Managing Partner and Chief Executive Officer of Corbin Capital Partners. She shares her views on alternative investments, how the firm has incorporated ESG into its principles, her experience being a woman in alternative investments, what the firm is doing to champion D&I and more.

Investing in Diverse and Emerging Managers
Investing in Diverse and Emerging Managers

Elana Margulies-Snyderman speaks with Kelly Chesney, Co-Founder of Pluscios Management. She shares her views on alternative investments, how she got into money management, how her firm has been a pioneer in investing in diverse and emerging managers, her experience being a women in investing, what her firm is doing to champion more women at a young age to foray into money management.

Private Equity Investing in Media and Entertainment
Private Equity Investing in Media and Entertainment

In this episode of we speak with Vania Schlogel about her views on private equity, the specific opportunities she sees, why she opened an office in South Korea, her experience being a woman in the industry and more.

Latino Money Manager Empowers Young Hispanics to Foray Into Money Management
Latino Money Manager Empowers Young Hispanics to Foray Into Money Management

Lorenzo Esparza discusses his views on alternative investments, how he got into money management, what is he doing to champion more young Hispanics to go into investing careers.

Raising Capital When Everyone Is Scared: A Conversation with Garry Jensen
Raising Capital When Everyone Is Scared: A Conversation with Garry Jensen

As we continue to explore the capital raising environment for funds in a virtual context against a backdrop of economic uncertainty, we turn to Garry Jensen, Managing Partner of Jensen Capital Partners, to get his insights.

Raising Capital When Everyone Is Scared: Do Investors Really Buy Low?
Raising Capital When Everyone Is Scared: Do Investors Really Buy Low?

In this podcast, we look to Julia Mord for her perspective on asset allocation, manager selection, and market conditions.

Innovation In Private Equity Using Structured Financial Products
Innovation In Private Equity Using Structured Financial Products

In this podcast Christopher Mizer of Vivaris Capital, delves into what structured financial products are and why they are attractive investment opportunities to investors.